Wick's Pizza Parlor & Pub

03/07/03

Best in the World

by samcfitz at Citysearch

If you want pizza..then this is it. I've only eaten there 3 times. In my opinion the best Pizza in the Midwest and probably the Nation!

• Pros: Tasteful
• Cons: Waiting, Crowded

11/09/09

Awesome!

by rwcantrell at Citysearch

We were invited to meet up with friends and this was our first time. We loved the pizza,

the drinks, the friendly, efficient service

and had a good time with our friends.

• Pros: Good service, good pizza , good time
• Cons: parking

06/06/09

Absolutely the best anywhere

by kahc at Citysearch

My family travels a lot and we always try a local pizza place - not a franchise. This one is by far the best pizza that we have found. We live 3 1/2 hours away from Wick's Pizza and have literally gotten up on a Saturday and driven to Louisville just for pizza.

12/12/08

awesome!

by prisilla769 at Citysearch

My hairstylist is located just a few doors down from Wicks and had recomended that I try the chicken club. It was freaken awesome!!!! yummy

10/31/08

FAIR AT BEST AND NOT REALLY AUTHENTIC AT ALL

by bucko8300 at Citysearch

EDIBLE, WITH DECENT FLAVOR, BUT FAR TOO WEIGHTY WITH TOPPINGS, CAN'T REALLY TASTE CRUST. MOSTLY GENERIC AS MOST COMMERCIAL TAKE OUT IN THIS CITY. A FAR CRY FROM THE REAL THING.

• Pros: GREAT SERVICE AND FRIENDLY ATMOSPHERE
• Cons: STEAK SANDWICH JUST PLAIN AWFUL

08/05/08

Pizza, the right way

by m0wry at Citysearch

I'm a pizza fanatic. Originally from Omaha where the best Pizza in the world resides (Mama's, Big Freds, Godfathers, Sgt Peffers, etc)

Get the Big Wick. I'd give it a 5, but it was heavy on the green olives (a bit too much for my taste). My feeling is that you have to be sparing with canned green olives, or they will hijack your pizza.

The atmosphere is not my taste (loud), so I'd suggest sitting outside

If you are in Louisville, go.

• Pros: Pizza, Service
• Cons: Atmosphere, ambience, noise

06/30/08

Hands Down the BEST PIZZA IN LOUISVILLE

by xmarycontraryx at Citysearch

After moving to Louisville from NYC, I was so thrilled to be in walking distance of Wick's on Baxter. This is by far the best pizza in Louisville and even rivals some of my favorite pizza joints in NYC. The toppings are always fresh (I love the spinach, garlic and mushroom) and the service is always great! I take all of my guests from NYC there and they all STILL talk about the breadsticks and garlic butter. One friend even made me go back three nights in a row, he just couldn't get enough! I usually end up getting carry-out or delivery since the place is so busy inside. But who can complain? Of course it's busy, it's friggin delicious!

Check out the breadsticks, house salad, stuffed breadwick or the cinnamon star. All are amazing! And whatever you do, don't pass on the garlic butter dipping sauce. But beware... it is HIGHLY ADDICTIVE!!!

• Pros: Great food and beer menu, fresh ingredients.
• Cons: Parking is a nightmare

06/01/07

Extremely poor service/OK pizza

by redking at Citysearch

Went to Wick's for the first time after hearing people absolutely gush about the pizza there. First, the parking wasn't very good. We got inside and were seated quickly but it was very crowded and we almost didn't fit at the table we were seated at. There weren't any more options though. After that, we saw or server less and less. It was absolutely unreal the amount of time it took to get our food. We could not get our waitress to come back to the table for re-fills or anything else. The pizza was good, but nothing to write home about. After waiting for almost a half our to get our ticket, we were almost ready to just leave we were so frustrated. She finally came back and it was wrong. Needless to say, I am definitely in no rush to go back there.

• Cons: Sloooooow service, loud

06/08/06

not what it's cracked up to be

by bethg193 at Citysearch

People swear by Wick's. Maybe you have to be a Louisville native to appreciate their pizza, but I found it boring and unappetizing. Each slice is weighed down with a mountain of cheese (and not even GOOD cheese) that takes over the flavor of the sauce and crust. Any pizza place that offers a chicken bacon ranch pizza seems un-authentic to me. I find it rather pricey as well. There are other local pizza establishments that I would choose before Wick's. Not impressed.

03/14/06

Best Pizza in town

by jicah8 at Citysearch

This is definately the best pizza in town period....HOwever a trip to wick's also gets you the best atmosphere and service of any pizza place in town. Also this is probably the 2nd best pizza in the country behind Giordano's in Chicago!

• Pros: deliscious, great service, deliscious
• Cons: parking

12/28/05

Awesome food

by virtualvalerie at Citysearch

By far the pizza is one of a kind. I've read how the sauce isn't much in flavor, but in my opinion it compliments the ingredients. This is a great sports bar, too. I go to the Baxter location every Sunday for NFL. It's a great place to hang out with the regulars. Highly recommend this pizza.

• Pros: Unique flavor, Great sports bar, great service